Personalisation Without Intrusion: How Brands Can Earn Consumer Trust in the AI Age

Personalisation is one of marketing’s greatest paradoxes. Done well, it makes customers feel understood and valued. Done poorly, it feels invasive—like when you mention a holiday in conversation, and suddenly your entire feed is full of flight ads.

The problem isn’t personalisation itself. Consumers want tailored experiences, but they’re increasingly sceptical about how brands collect and use their data. 72% say they won’t engage with brands they don’t trust with their privacy (PwC, 2022).

With third-party cookies disappearing, AI reshaping marketing, and regulators tightening privacy laws, brands need to rethink how they deliver personalisation. The future belongs to those who can strike a balance between relevance and respect for consumer trust.

Why Consumers Don’t Trust Personalisation Anymore

For years, brands tracked users silently in the background—collecting data without clear consent. Now, with Apple’s App Tracking Transparency (ATT) and Google’s Privacy Sandbox, consumers have more control over who collects their data.

But giving users the power to opt out has revealed a bigger issue: most brands never built a trust-based data relationship to begin with. Without transparency, personalisation feels like surveillance rather than a service.

To earn trust, brands need to shift from passive data collection to active engagement—showing customers what’s collected, why, and what they get in return.

How to Get Personalisation Right Without Losing Trust

1. Be Transparent About Data Collection

Consumers don’t read 20-page privacy policies, and they shouldn’t have to. Clear, real-time visibility into data use is the future.

• Monzo’s banking app shows users exactly how their data is being used.
• Brands should introduce data dashboards, simple opt-in controls, and clear messaging around data use.

Transparency isn’t just a legal requirement—it’s a competitive advantage.

2. Make Data Sharing a Two-Way Exchange

Most brands collect data without offering anything in return. But when consumers see real value, they’re willing to share.

Spotify Wrapped makes personalisation feel fun and rewarding, not invasive.

Sephora’s Beauty Insider programme asks users for preferences in exchange for tailored recommendations and perks.

The key? Make personalisation feel like a service, not surveillance.

3. Let Consumers Shape Their Own Personalisation

Great personalisation isn’t something done to consumers—it’s something they actively shape.

Netflix’s “Thumbs Up/Thumbs Down” system lets users curate recommendations without excessive tracking. Brands should move to preference-based models where consumers feel in control of their experience.

4. Use AI to Build Trust, Not Erode It

AI personalisation doesn’t have to be invasive—if done ethically.

• Use AI on anonymised data rather than hyper-targeting individuals.
• Be transparent when AI is shaping recommendations.
• Avoid bias by applying ethical AI frameworks (e.g., Fjord’s Responsible AI model).

AI should enhance trust—not undermine it.

The Future of Personalisation: Trust is the Differentiator

The brands that win in the privacy-first era will be the ones that make personalisation feel like a benefit, not a trade-off.

Consumers aren’t asking for less personalisation—they’re asking for better personalisation. That means:

• Less tracking, more consumer control.
• Less data extraction, more value exchange.
• Less silent AI, more transparent engagement.

Trust isn’t just an ethical consideration—it’s a business advantage.

How BBD Can Help

At BBD, we help brands navigate the intersection of AI, personalisation, and consumer trust—ensuring marketing is impactful, ethical, and future-proof.

Using our Smart Craft framework, we help brands:

• Leverage AI for intelligent, ethical personalisation.
• Design transparent, trust-building customer experiences.
• Shift from passive data collection to active consumer engagement.

The future of marketing isn’t about knowing everything about your customers—it’s about making them comfortable with what you know.

Found this interesting? Want to get this balance right? 

Get in Touch!